A technology focus area of the Cryogenics Test
Laboratory is thermal insulation systems. The development of cost-effective,
robust cryogenic insulation systems that operate at soft-vacuum level is
a primary target from the energy and economics point of view. This applied
research and development work includes the test, evaluation, characterization,
and application of silica aerogel beads produced by Cabot Corporation.
The aerogel bead material has many potential applications for cryogenic
and other higher-performance insulation needs in industry. Evaluation activities
include novel composite constructions and larger-scale applications such
as cold boxes. The material has been proposed for insulating cryogenic
umbilical connections for new commercial launch platforms, retrofitting
perlite-insulated storage dewars, and insulating a miles-long cryogen transfer
line. Over 100 liquid nitrogen boiloff tests of the aerogel products using
research cryostats have been performed. Characterization information, such
as evacuation, outgassing, and ease of use, is also being obtained. The
thermal performance data are being used in the preliminary development
of future space launch and exploration applications.
The aerogel beads have a bulk density of about 80 kilograms per cubic
meter (kg/m3) and a mean particle diameter of 1 millimeter (mm).
The typical
pore diameter of the particles is about 120 angstroms. Production of
the aerogel beads employs a continuous spray process of manufacturing.
The
ambient drying step replaces the costly supercritical drying step characteristic
of most aerogels produced by solution-and-gelation (sol-gel) methods.
The beads are treated to remain hydrophobic, but a hydrophilic
(untreated)
product is also available for oxygen service. The properties of aerogel
beads are given as follows:
Property |
Value |
Nominal Diameter
|
1 mm |
Bead Density
|
140 kg/m3 |
Bulk Density
|
80 kg/m3 |
Surface Area
|
650 m2/g |
Pore Volume
|
3.17 cm3/g |
Outgassing
|
Less than 1%
to total mass loss |
Flammability
|
Noncombustible |
Minimum Ignition
Temperature
|
400 oC |
Properties of Aerogel Beads
Steady-state liquid nitrogen boiloff methods were used to characterize
the thermal performance of aerogel beads in comparison with conventional
insulation products such as perlite powder and multilayer insulation
(MLI). Test articles are heated and evacuated to below 10-5 torr
to begin a test
series. The cold vacuum pressure (CVP) is adjusted for the desired
vacuum level using nitrogen as the residual gas. A thermal shroud
maintains the insulation outer surface (warm boundary temperature
[WBT]) at approximately
293 K. (See figure 1.) The cold mass (cold boundary temperature
[CBT]) is kept at approximately 80 K. After coincident stability
of the
vacuum level, all layer temperatures, and the evaporation (boiloff)
rate are
achieved,
the apparent thermal conductivity (k-value) is determined from
Fourier’s
law of heat conduction for a cylindrical wall.
The materials tested were aerogel beads (81 kg/m3), opacified aerogel
beads (94 kg/m3, carbon black R300), perlite powder (115 kg/m3,
50 x 50 mesh),
and MLI (92 kg/m3, 60 layers aluminum foil and fiberglass paper). All test
specimens were made in a cylindrical configuration at a typical thickness
of 25 mm. A summary graph of the k-value as a function of CVP is given
in figure 2. The experimental curves for perlite and MLI compare well with
similar thermal performance data from the literature. The aerogel beads
gave superior performance for all CVP’s above 0.1 torr. The carbon
black opacifier improved the performance of the aerogel beads for CVP’s
below 10 torr. The high-vacuum (1 x 10-4 torr) performance of the
plain white aerogel beads is approximately 1.1 milliwatts per meter-kelvin
(mW/m-K),
while that of the opacified specimen is approximately 0.6 mW/m-K. The
added radiation shielding effect of the opacifier yielded almost 50-percent
improvement.
The k-values for the aerogel beads were found to be comparable to the
performance of other aerogel-based products under similar cryogenic vacuum
conditions.
The results showed the performance of the aerogel beads was significantly
better than the conventional materials in the soft-vacuum to no-vacuum
range. Opacified aerogel beads performed better than perlite powder under
high-vacuum conditions.
|
|
The results of this
experimental research study of aerogel beads show that this new product
offers several performance advantages in comparison to the more conventional
thermal insulation products currently available for cryogenic applications.
The following characteristics are some key advantages of the aerogel
beads: free flowing, fill small cavities, minimal dusting, nonsettling,
do not compact, no preconditioning needed, and can be molded or formed
using binders. Thermal performance for the actual use conditions between
liquid nitrogen temperature and room temperature was determined to
be approximately 11 mW/m-K at no vacuum and 1.1 mW/m-K (0.6 mW/m-K,
opacified) at high vacuum. Further studies for material optimization
and system application are in progress.
Looking for cost-effective solutions to insulation problems is fundamental
to the energy-intensive field of cryogenics and, in general, to the endeavors
of space travel. A successful production chain for the aerogel beads and
similar nano-technology materials will be an important part of these efforts.
Maturation of the production processes can then lead to wide-scale usage
in practically all refrigeration industries including food processing,
storage, and transportation; air conditioning and environmental control;
medical and biological applications; and manufacturing processes.

Figure 1. Overall View of Insulation
Test Cryostat Apparatus
Figure 2. Variation of k-Value With CVP for
Different Insulation Materials
Contact:
J.E. Fesmire (James.Fesmire-1@ksc.nasa.gov),
YA-C2, (321) 867-7557
Participating Organizations: Dynacs Inc. (Dr. S.D. Augustynowicz) and Cabot Corporation
(S. Rouanet)
|